A Novel by Gary Sprague
– Review by Mark E. Welch
– Jake Adler’s story in Prescott Falls, Maine, makes for a thoroughly enjoyable mystery with warmth, humor, and genuine suspense. From the opening setup, the book does an excellent job of grounding the reader in Jake’s comfortable but quietly complicated life: his lake house, his handyman work, and, best of all, his loyal chocolate lab, Charlie. That sense of place and personality gives the story an inviting charm before the mystery even begins, making it easy to settle in and care about what happens next.
The return of Julia Fallon adds emotional depth as well as intrigue. Her history with Jake gives the story more than a simple whodunit structure; there is unresolved heartbreak, old chemistry, and the awkwardness of being forced back together under the worst possible circumstances. When Julia’s husband is murdered and both she and Jake become suspects, the stakes feel personal rather than procedural. Jake is not a polished detective, which makes him even more compelling. His background as a fired former police officer and his jiu-jitsu training give him just enough confidence to get involved, but not so much that he ever feels unbelievable.
What makes the book especially satisfying is the balance between danger and personality. The murder investigation keeps the plot moving, while Jake’s voice, his bond with Charlie, and the small-town atmosphere give the story heart. The threat surrounding Jake, Julia, and Charlie builds tension without losing the lighter, character-driven qualities that make the book so readable. It is the kind of mystery that offers enough suspense to keep pages turning while still giving readers characters they want to spend time with.